logo  ELT Concourse teacher training
Concourse 2

Comparison

comparison

Making comparisons is a key communicative skill.  Unfortunately, it's also a neglected skill because most teaching starts and stops with a consideration of how we form comparative statements with adjectives and adverbs and how we use the conjunctions than and as/so ... as to connect the ideas.
As we shall see, there's rather more to it than that.


adjectives

Adjective comparison

There is no great mystery to how we use adjectives to make comparisons with either the than or the as/so ... as formulation.  For example:
    She is older than I (the inflected form)
    That's more expensive than this
(the periphrastic form)
    That's not so nice as mine
    This is as good as it gets

etc.
At this point, it is important that you understand the difference between the periphrastic forms (more, most and less, least) and the inflected forms (the addition of -er and -est).

equal

Equality

The usual ways in which adjectives and adverbs are used to express equality is by using the as ... as formulation in, e.g.:
    This is as big as a house
    I am as old as you
    It is as beautiful as a flower

etc.
It used to be suggested that the negative form should be the so ... as formulation as in, e.g.:
    It's not so long as the other one
    They are not so old as their cousins

etc.
In modern English, the distinction is no longer adhered to and not worth teaching.
The only thing to note is that the so ... as formulation is

  1. more formal
  2. not allowed in affirmative statements so we cannot have
        *She is so good at mathematics as you

The second part of this correlating conjunction is frequently elided.  For example:
    This is not as/so good (as something else)

form

Form: inflexion or periphrasis?

The rules in English for making the comparative and superlative forms of adjectives are slightly complicated.  Often, they are abbreviated for pedagogical purposes to something like:
    Use the -er / -est endings + ...than... for short adjectives and the more / most + ...than... for longer adjectives.
For elementary learners, that may suffice but it will lead to error because it oversimplifies to the point of inaccuracy.  Structural errors such as:
    This is the boringest book I have ever read
    She is a carefuller driver than you

will arise by applying rules like this and even phonological errors such as pronouncing simpler as /ˈsɪm.pələ/ instead of /ˈsɪm.plə/ may also follow.

Here's a run-down of the major rules that learners need to assimilate at some point:

  1. It is possible to use periphrastic forms with all adjectives, especially when use predicatively.  For example:
        Donald Trump is wealthy but Bill Gates is more wealthy
    This is especially the case when the amplifier adverb even is added to the mix:
        She was rude but her husband was even more rude.
    But:
    1. A number of common monosyllabic adjectives resist the periphrastic forms and these include:
      big, clean, far, fast, great, high, low, old, young, small, thick, thin, wide.
    2. The adjectives good and bad always resist the periphrastic forms.
  2. If the sound at the end of the adjective is an unstressed vowel (such as /i/, /l/ or /ə(r)/, then the inflexional change is most common:
        noisier, wealthier, chubbier, narrower, gentler, subtler, cleverer, maturer etc.
    To this list we can add some common disyllabic ones such as common, quiet, handsome, polite etc.
  3. With other disyllabic adjectives the periphrastic form is preferred:
        more basic, most comic, more pot-bound, most hated etc.
  4. Adjectives formed by suffixation with -ful, -ish and -less always make the comparative and superlative forms periphrastically:
        more useful, most foolish, more hopeless etc.
    All adjectives formed with -able and -ible are at least trisyllabic so follow the same pattern.
  5. No participle adjectives, however long or short, inflect (we always have the periphrastic more tiring and most bored, not *tiringer, injureder or *boredest).
  6. The periphrastic forms, more and most, have antonyms in less and least:
        more clever > less stupid
        more interesting > less boring

    The meaning and emphasis are different, of course.
  7. The syllabic '-le' ending (/əl/) on words like simple, humble etc. changes to a non-syllabic /l/ when used in the comparative or superlative form.  (So, e.g., humbler is pronounced /ˈhʌm.blə/ not /ˈhʌm.bələ/.)
  8. Spelling changes are:
    1. final consonants are doubled if the preceding vowel is a stressed single letter:
      big > biggest
      fat > fatter

      etc.
    2. when the base ends in a consonant + 'y', the 'y' is dropped and 'i' is substituted:
      early > earlier
      snappy > snappiest

      etc.
    3. when the base ends in a silent -e, it is dropped:
      sure > surer
      safe > safer

      (An alternative way to state this rule for learners is to say that only -r or -st rather than -er or -est is added in this circumstance.)
  9. There's a group of common adjectives which make comparative and superlative forms from different roots:
        good-better-best, bad-worse-worst, far-further/farther-furthest/farthest.
  10. The form of older commonly used in family relationships, elder-eldest, can only be used attributively (as in the eldest daughter not *the daughter is eldest).  Older than is preferred to *elder than.
  11. The adjectives well and ill referring to health form the comparatives with better and worse and have no superlative forms.
taller and older

Pronouns and case

taller and older than me  

Pedants among us will consume quite a lot of energy telling us that the correct form of the pronoun after than is the nominative case, I, we, they rather than the accusative case me, us, them etc.  Accordingly, it may be insisted that
    He is older than me
is wrong and should be
    He is older than I
or
    They work harder than us
is wrong and should be
    They work harder than we
The justification for this lies in reinserting the elided item and making the sentences as
    He is older than I am
and not the clearly wrong
    *He is older them me am
or
    They work harder than we work
and not
    *They work harder than us work
etc., thus demonstrating that the pronoun is actually the subject of the verb, not its object or complement.

Informally, at least, the accusative forms of the pronouns are at least as common as the 'correct' nominative pronouns.
In fact, the use of an accusative, object form of the pronoun can also be justified by classifying than as a preposition rather than a conjunction.  In English, all prepositions are followed by the accusative case.  In an expression such as
    The car weighs more than a ton
the word than is a preposition because we cannot re-phrase the clause as
    *The car weighs more than a ton weighs

To add to this mix, we need to consider some potential ambiguity.  Consider these two sentences:
    She likes you more than I
    She likes you more than me
In the first sentence, the meaning is that
    She likes you more than I like you
but in the second sentence, the meaning is that
    She likes you more than she likes me
It is only by insisting on the use of the correct case for the pronoun that the ambiguity can be avoided so the informal
    She likes you more than me
could carry either meaning.


shout

Adverb comparison

speak more assertively  

Adverbs generally follow the same set of rules that we saw above for adjectives.  The difference is that adverbs which end in -ly take the periphrastic form rather than the inflected form so we get, e.g.:
    happily > more happily > most happily
    gently > more gently > most gently

etc.
For example:
    They played more happily in the sunshine
    She spoke the most gently of them all

etc.

Here are the exceptions:

  1. Two adverbs ending in -ly do not follow the rules:
    1. early can function as an adjective or an adverb as in:
          the early bus (adjective)
      and
          they came early (adverb)
      In both cases, the word follows the adjective form in the comparative and superlative:
          early > earlier > earliest
      so we get, e.g.:
          We arrived earlier than you
    2. The adverb badly takes the comparative and superlative forms of the adjective bad:
          badly > worse > worst
      so we get, e.g.:
          They played worse than you
  2. There are a number of adverbs that are identical to the adjective forms, including, commonly, late, hard, fast and long.  These form the comparatives and superlatives by inflexion as in, e.g.:
        He hit it harder and harder
        They arrived later than you
        He drove faster than I could
        He spoke longer than was advisable

    etc.
  3. The adverb soon has no equivalent adjective and follows the rules as for an adjective:
    The sooner we get there the better
  4. The adjectives quick, loud and cheap are often used adverbially in informal English so we get, e.g.:
        I bought it cheaper than I thought possible
        He played the music louder and louder
        I drive quicker than her
    (There are many who aver that these forms are wrong but, informally at least, they are commonly heard.)
  5. A phenomenon known as the proleptic use of adjectives allows for what seems to be a verb modified by an adjective rather than an adverb.  For example:
        Roll the dough flatter
        Hammer the sheet thinner
        Screw the bolt tighter

    It is not, in fact, that case that these modifiers are referring to the verb.  What they are referring to is the end state of the noun phrase.  The word proleptic means looking forward or anticipating a state to be reached.

hotter

the .... the comparison

the hotter the better  

This construction, which has parallels in many languages, is a correlative subordinator.  It is unique in this role in English in expressing proportional comparison, i.e., comparing relative notions of one thing rising or falling in parallel with another.  It can link a variety of grammatical elements (although it is often, sadly, taught only as an adjective linker):

  • Linking adjectives:
        The hotter the weather, the lazier I get
  • Linking adverbs and adjectives:
        The faster he drove, the more frightened I became
        The longer I waited, the more irritated I became
  • Linking nouns and adjectives:
        The more people, the noisier the party will be
  • Linking verbs and adjectives:
        The more he shouted, the redder he became
  • Linking verbs and nouns:
        The more I drove the greater my tiredness

In this construction, the restrictions on the periphrastic forms with short adjectives are not so severe so, e.g.:
    The more old he became the more wise people thought him
is acceptable but
    *He is more old
is not.
The conjunction can, in other words, be used with both the inflexional and periphrastic forms of adjectives.
The conjunction has become institutionalized in some fixed expressions such as the more the merrier, the sooner the better etc.


modify

Modification of comparatives and superlatives

Expressions of comparison can be pre-modified with amplifiers and downtoners:

  • with amplifiers, for example:
    • that's much better
    • that's far worse
    • it's a lot less interesting
    • it's obviously more expensive
    • he drives much more carefully now
    • she arrived a good bit sooner than I
    • the film was great, the book yet/even greater
  • with downtoners, for example:
    • that's rather more exciting
    • she arrived slightly sooner
    • they were hardly any more useful
    • he drove a little more slowly
    • it seemed relatively / comparatively more important
restriction

Restrictions with fairly, quite and rather

These common adverb modifiers are restricted in the way they modify comparative and superlative phrases.

  • The adverb modifier fairly cannot be used at all with either comparative or superlative expressions, so we do not allow, e.g.:
    • *That's fairly better
    • *That's fairly more expensive
    • *This is fairly the best
    • *That's fairly the most important
  • The modifier quite can be used with its sense of completely to modify superlative phrases, so we allow, e.g.:
    • This was quite the best meal I've eaten here
    • She was quite the most skilful musician in the school
  • However, quite cannot be used with comparative expressions, so we do not allow, e.g.:
    • *That was quite the more important point
    • *He was quite happier
  • The modifier rather can be used to amplify comparative phrases, so we allow, e.g.:
    • That was rather nicer than I expected
    • She was rather ruder than she should have been
  • However, rather cannot be used to modify superlative expressions, so we do not allow, e.g.:
    • *He was rather the most intelligent boy in my class
    • *She was rather the best musician

Equivalent expressions in other languages do not invariably, or at all, have these restrictions so the point needs to be taught not assumed.


compare

The functions of comparative clauses

A comparative phrase can perform five grammatical functions:

  1. It can be adverbial as in
        She arrived much sooner than me
  2. It can be the subject of the verb
        Many more people believed him than didn't
  3. It can be the complement of a copular verb
        She is so much happier than she was
  4. It can be the direct object of the verb
        I bought more food than anyone else
  5. It can be the indirect object of the verb
        She gave more children a good home than anyone else

conjunct

Adverbials and conjunctions

Adjuncts, conjuncts, conjunctions, disjuncts and prepositional phrases are frequently used to express notions of comparison.  The distinction between a conjunct and a conjunction is not central to this guide but, if you are curious, try the guide to conjunction for an explanation.  There is also a guide to adjuncts, conjuncts and disjuncts.

Adjuncts
Adjuncts serve to add information to the verb phrase and two adverbs in particular express the notion of comparison:
    This is comparatively urgent
    He became relatively rich
Conjuncts
Conjuncts fall outside the clause structure and usually serve to link ideas between sentences.  Those that act to express comparison include, for example:
    The meeting will be long, I'm afraid, but, more importantly, it will concern all departments
    He was much admired for his leadership.  Less well known was his technical expertise
    She is a very good player.  The same may be said of her sister
    The government has been heavily criticised and likewise the opposition
    This is important but, on the other hand, so is the current problem
    She dances well.  By contrast/comparison, her brother has two left feet
Conjunctions
Conjunctions are an integral part of a clause and removing them usually leaves nonsense.  To express comparison of some sort, they are usually subordinating or coordinating conjunctions.  Both the word than and the as ... as form are conjunctions but others can be used.  For example:
    He came by car whereas I walked
    They arrived early but she late
    What you say now is true although that wasn't always the case
Disjuncts
Disjuncts show the speaker's attitude or the angle and are slightly rarer as indicators of comparison.  For example:
    Relatively speaking, this is not so important
    Comparatively viewed, this is less important
Prepositions
Some prepositions can be used to take the place of the conjunction than.  For example:
    The price is higher vis-à-vis that of the competition
    The price is lower against/beside/alongside/versus that of the competition

auroch

Verbs and nouns expressing comparatives

We saw above that phrases of comparison can function grammatically in five ways and speakers / writers often deploy a range for effect or to achieve the required style.
Particularly in academic English, verbal expressions, usually of relation, are used instead of the straightforward comparative forms of adjectives or adverbs.  Nouns, too, often derived from the same verbs, are used in the same way.  Their use is often combined with conjuncts and conjunctions.  For example:

Instead of ...  ... we get ... 
The number of people entering the country is more than it was The rate of immigration is rising
People are buying more butter than margarine The sale of butter is outpacing that of margarine
Butter is more expensive than margarine Margarine outprices butter
Arsenal played better than Chelsea Arsenal outplayed Chelsea
There are many more female students studying engineering these days The numbers of female students studying engineering shows a marked increase
I like Mozart more than Bach I prefer Mozart to Bach
The government is less popular than the opposition The government's popularity is lower, compared with the opposition
He worked faster than me He worked with more speed than I did
She is happier than you Her happiness exceeds yours
They offered more money than I could They outbid me

and so on.
For students whose need is for academic English or who will need to write formal essays comparing and contrasting, the ability confidently to employ verbs and nouns which express comparison is, of course, invaluable.


languages

Other languages

All languages have a way of making comparatives and superlatives, of course.  How they do it may lead to errors in the production of learners of English.  It is impossible to be comprehensive in what follows but the range of ways is some indication of the challenges facing learners of English.

  • Isolating languages such as Chinese do not rely on inflexion to change the meaning of words and, as one would expect, use a particle (translatable often as than) to show that one thing is being compared to another and adjectives are not inflected.  The order of words is often a source of error in English such as:
        *The house than the cottage comfortable (meaning The house is more comfortable than the cottage)
  • Japanese and Korean, too, form the comparative with a particle and make no change to the adjective.  However, word order differences can lead to errors such as:
        *London is Tokyo more cold (meaning London is colder than Tokyo)
        *The cottage more small the house
  • Many inflecting languages (especially European ones including most Germanic, Scandinavian and Slavic languages) do not employ the periphrastic formulations, using only adjective inflexions to signal comparison, and that can lead to errors such as:
        *The house is comfortabler than the cottage
    Learners with these first languages should not, however, have difficulty with the as ... as construction since parallels exist.
  • Many languages (such as Arabic) do not have a copular verb like be and that can lead to errors such as:
        *The house more comfortable than the cottage
  • Arabic also has distinct forms of adjectives used in the comparative and superlative and does not always make a distinction between comparative and superlative and that can lead to error such as :
        *He better in the class
    The language also requires the insertion of a particle to signal comparison so the use of than in English should not cause a problem.
  • Greek only distinguishes between the comparative and superlative by the insertion of the definite article and that can lead to a similar mistake:
        *She is the taller in the class
  • Italic languages, such as Italian, French and Spanish, despite inflecting verbs heavily, do not inflect adjectives to show comparative and superlative meanings.  The periphrastic forms in English will be familiar by analogy but may be overused and lead to error such as:
        *The more big house
        *The most old church

In summary, presenting and practising ways to express comparative and superlative meanings need to focus explicitly on form because very few languages are at all similar to English in this respect (and most are considerably simpler).  Concept, on the other hand, is not problematic.
A little comparative language work can often alert learners to the need to be careful in this area and notice the differences between language structures.



Related guides
conjunction for a general guide
adverbials for a guide to adjuncts, conjuncts and disjuncts
adverb modifiers for more on emphasisers, amplifiers and downtoners
synonymy for more on the use of simile and as ... as formulations
adjectives for a guide which includes some consideration of comparison
adverbs for a guide which includes some consideration of comparison